November 15, 2026
By Stephen Stofka
Last week I wrote about the libertarian’s party belief that businesses can manage common action problems more efficiently than government. Government management does have several key weaknesses. However, private industry has some inherent flaws in managing these problems and I don’t think libertarians acknowledge those structural problems. Let’s dig in!
Performance Metrics
In the United States, as in most countries, there is no objective performance measure to evaluate the politicians who are supposed to represent the interests of their constituents. In the 1930s, during the Great Depression, economist Simon Kuznets first articulated a coherent philosophy of national income accounting. The version we are most familiar with is Gross Domestic Product (Source).
After World War 2, Kuznets preferred his “Variant III” measure which excluded national defense spending (Source). He thought this “peacetime” measure more accurately reflected the improvement in the welfare of American households. The Commerce Department nixed that idea because they wanted to include all government policy initiatives (Source). During the 1950s, defense spending was more than 70% of federal spending (Source). Today, it is 15% of Federal expenditures, or 4% of the nation’s GDP (Source).
When the economy is down, voters blame the President, but even when GDP growth is good, voters blame the President if groceries, gas and housing costs squeeze the budgets of many households. Such was the case in the recovery from the pandemic, what economist Kyla Scanlon called a “vibecession” (Source). Regardless of the numbers, people felt like it was a recession. President Biden’s mistake was to dismiss the public’s concerns. The voters made the Democrats pay for that in the 2024 election. Four years later, when the war with Iran drove up diesel and grocery prices, President Trump made the same mistake as Biden. In the midterm elections, the voters punished Trump’s lack of concern and the Republican Congress for letting him get away it.
Electoral Inertia
Why don’t voters hold Congress responsible for the lack of economic growth or high inflation? Congress writes the laws, and spends the money that affects American households. Congress is 535 members, a group so large and so diffuse that it is difficult to “pin the tail on the donkey,” so to speak. The President, just one person, is an easy target so he becomes the proverbial piñata.
Most of the members of the House are re-elected, yet a recent poll by Gallup indicated a 14% approval rating of Congress (Source). Due to the lack of performance metrics, voters re-elect their Congressional leaders until they get angry about something their representative has done, or a policy stance they have taken.
A candidate from the same party challenges the incumbent and a small number of voters choose the challenger over the incumbent. In some cases, voters are disappointed in the incumbent party and many do not vote. Voters of the other party, angry at the incumbent party, come out strongly and vote their candidate into office.
In our current system of government, a select few craft the choices of candidates and policies before they are presented to the voters. The majority decide neither the candidates nor the policies. This is a republic, not a democracy. Until the structure of the system is changed, it will remain a government by the few, and, all too often, for the few.
/////////////////////
Blueblood Beneficence
Bent below the yoke of grinding poverty and a crippled economy during the Great Depression, Americans voted for a change agent, a federal government that would alleviate their economic misery. Franklin Roosevelt, a governor of New York, was a member of the same family as former President Theodore Roosevelt. The family, wealthy and prominent in northeast politics, believed that those of substantial means had a civic duty to build public institutions and charitable organizations. Franklin, known to history by his initials FDR, answered the call and, in an effort to bring relief to the American people, created our modern federal bureaucracy by happenstance. Without some overarching vision, an alphabet soup of agencies was created to address unemployment, homelessness and hunger. The Supreme Court initially ruled that some programs were an unconstitutional exercise of executive authority but relented in Roosevelt’s second term. In the ensuing decades, the hodge-podge of agencies multiplied like rabbits. Today, the Federal Register lists 448 agencies (Source).
The Great Society
During World 2, spending on national defense consumed 84% of federal spending (Source). By 1950, defense spending decreased but, for most of the next two decades, rarely fell below 10% of GDP. In the late 1960s, spending on President Johnson’s Great Society Programs filled the gap left by the decline in defense spending. These programs included Medicare, Medicaid, Food Stamps and Child Nutrition, among others.
Article 1 of the Constitution tasked Congress with providing for the general welfare of the country. These programs accomplished that by helping individuals and families. Some interpreted the general welfare to mean only that welfare which applied to everyone generally. In 1965, spending on the Medicare program was estimated to be $12 billion by 1990. The actual costs were $90 billion (Source). Before the Great Society programs, inflation was 1.5%. By 1970, spending on the Vietnam War and the Great Society programs had helped to lift inflation to almost 5% by 1970.
Common Action Problem – Pollution
Rachel Carson’s book Silent Spring, published in 1962, alerted the American public to the growing dangers of pollution on animals and people. In 1969, the polluted Cuyahoga River in Ohio caught on fire, a vivid alarm to those dangers (Source). In 1970 President Nixon formed the Environmental Protection Agency, an umbrella organization that combined the work of more than a dozen bureaus that regulated and monitored pollution (Source). Although the agency was independent, Nixon thought he would have more control in a political environment where Democrats held large majorities in both houses of Congress.
Under the EPA, the federal government had extensive intrusion into the regulation, monitoring and planning decisions of state and local governments. Much air and water pollution is not confined to local areas, so the EPA acted as a coordinating and supervisory institution. At least, that was the theory. Too often, lower level employees imposed their interpretation of the relevant laws on local planning officials and businesses.
The Powell Memorandum
In 1971 the Chamber of Commerce, a lobbying group of prominent businesses, asked a corporate attorney by the name of Lewis Powell to write an essay arguing against the growing federal intrusion into the private sphere. Powell’s so called “memorandum” warned that the American system was under attack by the very institutions that had built America (Source – pdf).. Communists, new leftists, and revolutionaries were a minority of the American people, but their voices were echoed by colleges, churches, journals, arts and sciences, and the media. TV played an important role in shaping attitudes. Powell referred to a recent poll showing that half of students wanted socialization of basic industries. To combat the leftist ideology, companies had to invest in educational institutions, media organizations, and build a network of influence in the justice system.
Common Action Problems – Privatization
Libertarians claim that private industry is better than government in managing or resolving many domestic common action problems. Advocacy groups like ALEC promote privatization schemes. Government services are delegated not to publicly owned or customer owned utilities, but to private businesses. The business is given a monopoly and there is little or no public accountability. Adam Smith first observed that businesses wanted to become monopolies to maximize their profits. With a monopoly and a lack of public oversight, a business does not have to wring efficiencies out of its operation. It can avoid the constraints of profit that discipline the managers.
For the supplier of a good or service, profit is both a carrot and a stick. Profit motivation encourages businesses to find efficiencies in their operation. Having to earn a profit disciplines the managers of a business. When a business has a monopoly on a product or service, those two aspects of profit no longer apply.
Common action problems like poverty, homelessness, education, and infrastructure improvements consist of benefits that are difficult to measure. Private industry lives by profits measurable in dollars, not nebulous improvements in individual or general welfare. Without that monetary benchmark, private industry measures its returns in comparison to other performance metrics. Like racing greyhounds, they chase a mechanical rabbit like the performance of 10-year government bonds or the interest rate on Treasuries plus a small risk factor. For all their flaws, government institutions have consistently better accountability than private industry.
Next week I want to further explore how libertarian ideology has influenced tax legislation for the past few decades. Hope to see you then.
////////////////////
Photo by Dušan veverkolog on Unsplash