Drawing of an octopus

Governance Without Corruption

November 1, 2026

By Stephen Stofka

For the past few weeks, I have looked at the boundaries between individuals and government. We often think of government as a set of institutions ordered by a regime of laws, values and principles. Yes, government is an apparatus, but it is peopled by individuals who act within the influence of that culture, that regime. They are not automatons or puppets subject to the manipulation of masters behind the curtain. They act with intention.

Poor Governance

People have long expressed a lack of confidence in Congress. Gallup has long sampled Congressional approval among Americans. Only during the late 1990s and early 2000s did Congressional approval rise above 50%. Recently, Gallup’s results have reached all time lows near 10% approval (Source).

In The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State, Jill Lepore notes that “nearly two in five people surveyed across seventy countries agree with the statement, ‘AI could make better decisions on my behalf than my government representatives’” (p. 8). People worry about poor governance compounded by corruption.

A Government by the People

At the dedication ceremony following the Battle of Gettysburg during the Civil War, Lincoln wrote “that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth” (Source). He delivered that speech before the passage of the 14th Amendment, which guaranteed equal protection to all persons within the country (Source). In 1886, a note in a Supreme Court case, Santa Clara County v. Southern Pacific Railroad Co., the Supreme Court recognized a limited personhood for corporations. Roscoe Conkling, the lawyer for Southern Pacific, informed the justices that the 14th Amendment’s definition of “persons” included corporations.

Conkling had served as a Representative, a Senator and had turned down a nomination to be on the Supreme Court. Having been one of the drafters of the 14th Amendment, the justices on the court took him at his word. He may have been lying to serve the best interests of his client, the railroad (Source). He did not recognize the right of judicial review, that the court had the final say on an issue, so he might have excused his falsehood (Source).

In 1978, a divided court held that corporations had a First Amendment right to spend money on state ballot issues. In the 2010 Citizens United case, the court narrowly decided that corporations could spend money on candidates as well as issues, and at all levels (Source). Today, people feel that we do not have government by the people, nor for the people. We have government by big corporations, for big corporations. A well-intentioned falsehood in an 1886 case may have opened the door for rule by a corporate oligarchy. The process certainly invites corruption.

Corruption

Lord Acton was a 19th century English politician, writer and historian who penned the often quoted observation, “Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely” (Source). Corruption is the use of a public institution for private gain. Individuals divert public benefits and funding to themselves, their family and friends. Congress is a good example. Why do members of Congress amass such fortunes within a decade of being elected?

Jonathan Klick, a Professor at the University of Pennsylvania Law School, examined the growth in wealth of members of the House in the decade 2004-2014. Their average wealth grew seven times that of the top 5% of Americans on the income ladder. How did they outperform a lot of smart and talented people? Because House members are not required to reveal many details, Klick did not presume to explain the causes of that growth. Test takers achieve such extraordinary results by having access to the answers, hiring someone talented and knowledgeable to take the test, or having the ability to change the reported results. We can presume that there is some factor that gives members of Congress a financial edge.

The Role of Government

In third world countries with a weak private sector, government jobs offer people a chance at a middle class lifestyle. Winning candidates secure jobs for their family and friends. The purpose of government is to serve those in power who use government institutions to stay in power. It is a far cry from Lincoln’s vision as he articulated in the Gettysburg Address, but it was standard practice in 19th century America.

When President Andrew Jackson took office in 1829, he embraced the system of patronage and elevated it to a noble philosophy. He believed in a spoils system that, much like some third world countries today, reward the majority with jobs and benefits (Source).

Early in the course of the Civil War, the Union Army was plagued by a corrupt supply chain that sold inferior uniforms and horses to the army at exorbitant profits. In The First Tycoon, a biography of Cornelius Vanderbilt, T.J. Stiles recounts when President Lincoln approached Vanderbilt, a man known for getting things done, and offered him the post of Secretary of the Army. Vanderbilt turned down the position but did procure better quality goods at a fair price. Later, Vanderbilt chanced his fortune against the powerful Tammany Hall political machine that controlled rail transport in New York. Despite massive corruption and stock market manipulation by the machine, Vanderbilt busted the political monopoly that exercised an iron control on rail construction and access.

Private Property

A cornerstone of liberal democracy is the concept of private property. In 17th century Britain, a civil war erupted between monarchists, those loyal to the king and the power of the king, and Parliamentarians, those loyal to the Parliament as representatives of the people’s will. Robert Filmer, a noted monarchist, argued that the right to property comes from God through the King. John Locke argued that the right to property comes directly from God. When God drove Adam and Eve out of the garden, He told the couple they would have to work the land for their survival. Therefore, those who cultivate the land add value to the land and “thereby makes it his property” (PDF link, p. 116). The state merely recognizes that title.

In later centuries, the American colonists used this reasoning to deny that Indians had any right to the land since they did not improve it. In the plains states, 19th century settlers sometimes squatted on land in the hopes that the government would take the land from the Indians and sell it to settlers at a cheap price. Sometimes it did, sometimes not.

To encourage western expansion, railroads were given vast tracts of land in the plains and western states, and most of it was Indian land as acknowledged in earlier treaties. When the railroads were done building, they sold to the settlers at rates that were many times what the railroads had paid for the land. The Ingalls family, of Little House on the Prairie fame, were squatters on Osage Indian land in the Kansas territory. When the government did not follow through, the Ingalls had to move (Source).

In South Dakota, the Sioux Indians were not so lucky. In 1868, the Treaty of Fort Laramie set aside portions of South Dakota, Montana and Nebraska as a Sioux reservation inhabited by several Indian tribes. Six years later, gold was discovered in the Black Hills of South Dakota. A rush of prospectors overwhelmed Indian resistance and feeble government attempts to thwart the rush.

A country preserves its sovereignty by retaining the right to all land within its borders. Throughout the western states, the federal government claims ownership of most of the land, then leases it out for ranching and mining. The Fifth Amendment acknowledges the concept of private property when it states, “nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.” There must be an exchange. However, the amendment assumes that any taking of property by government is for “public use.” The country’s history is a litany of takings for private gain supposedly in advancement of a public cause like western expansion.

Conclusion

Knowing that government institutions are not made of pure virtue and run by people with a keen interest in their own self-interest, Libertarians have long sought to curb the scope of government. Next week I will explore the consequential people who are devoted to the Libertarian cause. Hope to see you then.

/////////////////////////

Photo by The Metropolitan Museum of Art on Unsplash

Small white dog looking at the camera from behind some leaves

Big Dog, Little Dog

October 25, 2026

By Stephen Stofka

Last week I looked at the persistent controversies within generations alive at the same time. This week, I want to explore the continuing tension between government institutions and the individuals who are subject to the jurisdiction of those institutions. Are we living in a nation of liberal principles or a dog park where the big dog, government, intimidates the little dogs?

Private Property

When the Soviet Union dissolved in 1991, residents of Russia were introduced to private property for the first time in 500 years. Just as the feudal system was weakening in the late 15th century, Ivan the Great had consolidated the Principality of Russia. Before then, many peasants were used to moving every three years in a system of slash and burn agriculture. The introduction of a feudal system enabled large estate owners to tie their workers to the land they owned. By the time of the American Declaration of Independence, the Russian feudal system had evolved into a system of near slavery. As the American Civil War erupted in 1861, Czar Alexander II emancipated the privately owned serfs of Russia (Source).

Why do nations permit individuals to own property? The majority of wealth held by Americans is in their home equity. Governments could lease those homes out to families and retain the implied wealth. In an agricultural society, the feudal lords used their serfs to farm the land. In our urban society, local governments farm people, not land. Wait, what?

This is a weekly exploration, an unraveling of thought threads so I am going to follow this one. Homeowners work for a variety of employers and earn income. Local governments get more in taxes per acre of land if people rather than crops live on the land. Taxing people is more lucrative than taxing crops. At the end of this essay, I have included the math on owning a home.

We may point to the 5th Amendment as an acknowledgment of the supremacy of private property but the 5th Amendment prohibits governments only from taking an individual’s property without just compensation. A government’s right to someone property is still supreme.

Cultivated Minds

Farming people requires more government investment per acre, similar to hydroponic farming. Crowding more people into an acre of land, requires more thorough weed control and cultivation. For weed control, governments use vaccines and other public health measures to check the spread of communicable diseases. The chief cultivation measure is public education.

As I noted two weeks ago, almost half of people lived on farms near the turn of the century. In 1900, only 10% of children attended high school. By 1930, only 25% lived on farms (Source). In those three decades, the percentage of children attending high school jumped from 10% to 50%. By 1940, it was almost 75% (Source). A continuing source of friction and resentment between parents and government is the idea of compulsory education. Parents, particularly those with a Biblical view of authority, regard the parents as the supreme authority over their children’s upbringing, not the government.

Education plays a role similar to fertilizer, weed control and cultivation. How so? A better educated workforce earns more income and can pay higher taxes. Public education socializes children at an early age and helps create a shared culture. This helps reduce violence among families from different cultural backgrounds who are tightly packed into dense urban areas. This

In 2025, the USDA estimated that fertilizer costs were about 40 – 45% of total costs for wheat and corn farmers (Source). The largest share of property taxes funds the local school district (Source – Power Schools). In my Colorado county, 49% of the tax is dedicated to various school funds.

In any community there are individuals who do not like to be “farmed.” Government institutions and programs try to standardize us the way that carrots, each of which is unique, is shaped, cut and polished to a standard baby-cut 2” length (Source).

Private schools can provide more rigorous educational standards or a learning culture that parents feel is more nourishing for their children. Naturally, they want their private choice to be funded with public dollars. If a state spent $10,000 per child on K-12 education, then a parent could apply a voucher for that amount to a private school. Currently, two-thirds of states have some form of school voucher but few have a truly universal voucher program that allows any family to fund a private school choice with public funds (Source).

Conclusion

In some respects governments act like feudal lords. A core tenet of liberal theory, first clearly articulated by the 17th century philosopher John Locke, is that people have natural rights. In a democracy or republic, government institutions are formed with the direct or indirect will of the people. Therefore, those institutions would also have natural rights. Big dog v. little dog and the big dog wins.

Next week I want to explore a fundamental libertarian belief that the scope of legitimate government power is very limited. In more than four decades, the Libertarian Party barely attracts any voter support. Is it an overly idealistic philosophy that rests more on attitude than consistent workable principles?

/////////////////////

Photo by Alvan Nee on Unsplash

////////////////////

Homeowner Math:  Consider a $500,000 home with a $400,000 mortgage and an annual property tax bill of $3000. In the first ten years of that mortgage, the amount of the mortgage payment that is applied to principal is less than the annual property tax bill.

Over decades, the annual price appreciation of homes has been about 4% so that a home’s price doubles in about 18 years. Let’s call it 20 years to make the math a bit easier. After 20 years, the value of that $500,000 home will have doubled to $1 million. The homeowner still owes $222K on the mortgage after paying $600K over that time, so the net equity is $778K.

Let’s say the homeowner has made $78K in improvements to make the math easier. If the house sold for $1 million after fees, the capital gain would be $700K. If the owners are a couple, they would have a $500K exclusion and a taxable gain of $200. Let’s say the capital gains tax rate is 15%, or $30000.

In those twenty years, the homeowner has paid the original $100K down, $600K in mortgage payments, $78K in improvements, $90K in property taxes and $30K in income taxes for a total of almost $900K. They have received the use of the house for 20 years and have netted $100K. However, that $100K is worth only $50K in buying power. Was the homeowner truly the landlord?

The Commons

Several hundreds of years before Adam Smith wrote his seminal work “The Wealth of Nations” (full text ), England wrestled with the Problem of the Commons, which is the title of a book by Gordon Marshall.

“The use of commons (publicly available land on which farmers graze their cattle) becomes a problem when one such farmer reasons that he or she can expand his or her herd since this small addition to the total stock will contribute little harm to the available pasture. However, if other farmers reason likewise, these incremental additions to the stock using the land lead to overgrazing and thus the destruction of the resource itself. In other words, if each individual in this situation rationally pursues his or her own short-term interest while disregarding others similarly pursuing theirs, then the long-run consequence is that everyone loses their share in the collective resource.” (GORDON MARSHALL. “Problem of the Commons.” A Dictionary of Sociology. 1998. Encyclopedia.com. 23 Sep. 2009)

Communism and other forms of collectivism try to solve this thorny problem by eliminating one of the sources of the conflict, private property. In an ideal form, free market capitalism denies the existence of the commons, thereby eliminating the other source of the problem.

Between those two extremes lie various attempts to form societies to manage, not solve, this enduring struggle, allowing the two competing interests of private and public to wrestle.