November 22, 2026
By Stephen Stofka
A brief pause of silence to remember the assassination of President Kennedy on this day 63 years ago.
These past few weeks I have been exploring the types of common action problems. There are two camps of thought, that government programs or private enterprise are the preferred solution. Libertarians prefer private enterprise for many types of problems, but the Libertarian Party has attracted little electoral success. This week I want to investigate how Libertarian principles have become embedded in public policy, particularly tax policy.
Tax Reform
As we get older, we appreciate the effect that history has on our current circumstances. High inflation in the 1970s aroused public outrage at the income tax code. Taxpayers paid higher tax rates at higher income levels or brackets, and the brackets were not indexed for inflation. A worker might have no increase in their inflation-adjusted income, but paid a higher percentage of their income in taxes, an inflation penalty.
In the 1970s, ordinary workers paid far higher taxes than they do today. A married couple earning $12,000 taxable income in 1979 paid 21% in federal income tax (Source). That $12,000 has as much buying power as $56,000 in 2026 (Source). A married couple with $56,000 in taxable income paid only 11% in 2025 (Source). What happened?
In the 1980 Presidential election, Ronald Reagan won the White House in part by appealing to this resentment against unfair taxation. In 1981, indexing income first became law but did not take effect until the 1985 tax year. The 1986 Tax Reform Act incorporated income indexing, eliminated a lot of deductions to broaden the tax base and lower tax rates for all income levels. While there have been a number of tax reforms since then, 1986 is the last bipartisan and comprehensive reform that was revenue neutral.
Showdown at Gucci Gulch by Jeffrey Birnbaum and Alan Murray (Source – Amazon) is an anecdotal account of the path to tax reform. Readers will get a sense of the chaotic scrum of powerful personalities and lobbying groups that constitutes policymaking in Washington.
Libertarian Influence
In 1984, Charles and David Koch funded an advocacy group Citizens for a Sound Economy to be part of the push for tax reform (Source). Fred Koch, their father, was an MIT trained chemical engineer who developed a more efficient way to refine petroleum. For decades, Fred fought the large oil companies who tried to block his refining method with extensive patent claims. After many years, he prevailed in court.
Fred developed a strong antagonism toward large organizations, both private and government, which used their size and influence to promote their own cause by curtailing the freedom of others. The brothers inherited this aversion to sprawling organizations and funded several research institutions, the Cato Institute and Heritage Foundation, which emphasized individual choice. This was probably their first attempt at direct advocacy for an issue, tax reform, which was on the public agenda in Washington.
Readers who want a deep dive into the history of the network of Libertarian affiliated organizations can read Nancy MacLean’s Democracy in Chains (Source – Amazon). I would not describe the book as fair-minded, but it is thoroughly researched. MacLean does not hide her criticism of Libertarian thinking or the movement’s efforts to influence public policy.
Tax reform was one part of a reaction to the collectivist trend in public policy during the decades following World War 2. During the Congressional debate leading to the passage of the Tax Reform Act, Grover Norquist, the founder of Americans for Tax Reform, pressured Republican members of the House and Senate to take a pledge not to raise individual or corporate tax rates. In the 1990s, Norquist expanded his efforts to include state and local officials in his tax pledge commitment (Source).
In 1993, President Clinton signed the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act passed by a Democratically controlled House and Senate. The Act raised the top individual rate to almost 40% and increased corporate tax on higher incomes. It also helped Republicans brand Democrats as the party of collectivist tax and spend policy.
In 1994, Republican congressman Newt Gingrich led a revolt against the status quo by taking control of the House from the Democrats who had held control for 40 years. Shortly before the midterm elections, Republicans introduced the Contract with America, a set of reforms that the party promised to implement with legislation in the House. Dick Armey, the Republican Conference Leader in the House, had become a convert to libertarian principles and was the primary author of the Contract. The midterm election also swung control of the Senate to the Republicans. However, their 53 seat majority was not enough to overcome a Democratic filibuster, which blocked most reform bills originating in the House.
The Republican anti-tax movement has had profound effects on the budget process and the deficit. The last time Congress passed its budget on time was in 1996. Funding is separated into 12 functions, each with their own appropriations bill. Since the financial crisis in 2008 – 2009, Congress can barely manage to pass even one appropriations bill by the start of its fiscal year in October (Source).
During the 1990s, higher tax rates on high incomes brought in a lot of capital gains tax revenue during the dot-com boom. For a few years in the late 1990s, the government actually had a budget surplus. In June 2001, just months after George Bush took office, Republicans passed a tax reform bill that lowered individual rates and phased out the estate tax. Three months later came the 9-11 attack. Republicans had long been deficit hawks, but the Bush Administration abandoned fiscal prudence when it started the Afghanistan and Iraq wars in response to the 9-11 attacks. In 2003, Republicans passed a tax reform bill that accelerated the tax cuts of 2001 and reduced capital gains rates. By the time Bush left office, the public debt had grown 67% during his eight years in office.
Tea Party
Fiscal prudence for thee, but not for me. Politicians insist on fiscal boundaries when the other party is in power. When they have the purse strings, they can justify the breaking of those fiscal boundaries. Libertarian sentiments within the Republican Party helped form the Tea Party, a reactionary force against bank bailouts by the Republican establishment and Democratic attempts to relieve financial stress on households as a result of the financial crisis. The movement gained momentum when Democrats took advantage of their filibuster proof Senate majority and attempted to pass comprehensive health care reform.
Helping to fund these efforts to shrink government were the Koch brothers. Their father, Fred, had fought the bigs, be it big corporate oligopolies or big government. Charles and David focused their funding efforts on attacks against big government programs. An offshoot of the Tea Party movement was the MAGA movement, a reaction against the mainstream Republican Party. In the 2016 election, the Kochs refused to endorse Trump, an authoritarian whose positions on immigration, tariffs and trade were anti-libertarian. In the 2020 election, they again refused to support Trump, and in the 2024 election, supported more conventionally conservative candidates like Nikki Haley. During these years, they concentrated their funding efforts on strengthening Republican control of the House and Senate and efforts to enact or preserve tax cuts (Source).
Democracy or Republic
Let me return to Nancy MacLean’s book on the history of the Libertarian movement. The League of Women Voters calls our system of government a republic and a representative democracy (Source). Throughout the history of this country, we have been arguing the point. MacLean makes it clear that she does not like the parts of the Constitution that have republican, small ‘r,’ elements. Representation in the Senate gives less populated states more legislative and electoral power per person. Legislatures in Republican dominated states are encouraged to override the will of the majority in their cities.
Republicans are playing against demographic trends that favor Democrats in urban districts. The 17th Amendment altered the Constitution to transfer the election of Senators from House legislatures to the voters. Since the amendment was ratified in 1913, Republicans have never had a filibuster proof majority of 60 members in the Senate. Urban voters tend to favor government solutions to common action problems. Voters in rural counties, feeling marginalized by long term demographic shifts to urban areas, have long sought ways to bend the rules to gain and maintain control of the political process. Until the 1960s, Democrats were the party that bent the rules to support rural voters, particularly in the southern states. Since then, it has been the Republicans.
Representation
People who favor democratic characteristics often fail to acknowledge its flaws, some of which I have outlined in previous weeks. Why should the 50.1% get to control the affairs of the 49.9%? Those in the majority cheer on the principle of democracy. Those in the minority try to change the rules so they can be in control.
I’ll pick a state with a low population at random. Take Kansas, for example, with a population of only 3 million. 71% of the population is urban and leans Democratic (Source), yet the state’s Senate and House are dominated by Republicans who have supermajorities in both houses (Source). The two-term governor, Laura Kelly, is a Democrat who holds several records for the number of laws passed by the Republican legislature that she has vetoed (Source).
Kansas passed a Constitutional amendment to institute home rule in 1961, but home rule does not grant blanket autonomy to cities (Source). Under the guise of uniformity, a state legislature can subject large cities to unpopular laws by making the law uniform for all cities in the state. A city like Hays, Kansas, with a 21,000 population, has little uniformity with Wichita, with a population of 401,000, yet they are both cities. Of the five cities with populations over 100K, four lean Democrat, yet they have little say in the legislature. The legislature conveniently gerrymanders the electoral districts to marginalize some voters while giving others a greater voice. As in many states, the state legislature controls school funding at the local level. The legislature has repeatedly fought the state’s own Supreme Court to deny the cities appropriations previously enacted into law (Source).
Conclusion
Principles on paper and principles in action can be contradictory. To my knowledge, the Koch brothers did not fund efforts to restrain a Republican Party eager to spy on its own citizens in the interests of national security. Did they protest the creation of the sprawling government behemoth called Homeland Security? No. Neither the brothers or the Libertarian movement is consistent in its support of individual freedom and unintrusive government.
Are we to suppose that libertarians are against taxes but not big boondoggle defense programs that necessitate higher taxes? Rich or poor, we are all subject to contradiction because we contain a multitude of sentiments and interests. We expect ideological purity from others, but not ourselves. Next week I want to explore this idea of ideological purity within political parties. I hope to see you next week.
////////////////// Photo by Morgan Bryan on Unsplash